TIA survey says: 3PLs’ revenue up over 10% quarter-over-quarter

“Problems attracting capacity have hurt the most among the smallest brokers,” the TIA said in its report. “They have responded by concentrating on the most attractive loads.”

For 3PLs in that smallest category, shipments in the third quarter were down 10.3% from the second quarter. But the size of the average invoice rose 19.5%, and the total revenue was up 7.2%. Margins, however, were a small 1.2%. 

By contrast, the margin for the 3PLs in the middle range — between $16 million and $100 million — came in at 9.4% on shipment volume that was up just 2.6%. Revenue climbed 7.1% and the average invoice amount rose 4.5%.

The biggest companies, those with revenue of more than $100 million, saw their average invoice amount actually decline 0.5% from the second quarter. Total shipments rose 7.5% and revenue was up 10.7%. But with a gross margin of 4.3%, the larger companies had the lowest of the three categories surveyed by TIA. 

What is particularly striking about the margin data is how red ink turned black between the second and third quarters. In the TIA’s second-quarter report, the margin for the middle sector of 3PLs was reported as a negative 4.4%. For the companies with revenue above $100 million, it was a negative 9.7%. The smallest companies had a positive margin of 6.9% in the second quarter. 

By contrast, in the third quarter, the smallest companies had the tightest margins and the margins for the other two categories were solidly positive. 

There was a significant divergence during the quarter among modes of transportation. Truckload brokered freight had a strong quarter, with total shipments rising 9.5% and the invoice per load climbing 5% to $2,410. The gross margin in truckload was 13.7%, up 90 basis points from the second quarter.   

During the quarter, LTL shipments brokered by 3PLs declined 2.5% from the second quarter of last year, to 130,886. However, the invoice per load was up 7.5% to $465 and the gross margin per load rose 13.5% to $97. The gross margin rose to 20.9%, an increase of 110 basis points. 

Intermodal freight handled by 3PLs clearly struggled. Total shipments were down 1.3%, the invoice amount per load was up just 1.2% to $2,685, and the gross margin was flat at 8.8%.

While many economist statistics have been mostly ignoring comparisons to corresponding periods of 2020 because of the pandemic, comparisons in trucking by now are against a third quarter of 2020, when a strong freight market was in full swing. The FreightWaves Outbound Tender Rejection Index for the third quarter of last year climbed steadily through the quarter, peaking at 26.88. By comparison, the OTRI for the third quarter of this year started at less than that number and closed out the quarter at 21.78.

Given that the third quarter of 2020 was relatively strong, the performance of the 3PL industry in 2021’s third quarter was notable in comparison. Total shipments in this year’s third quarter were up 10.6% from last year; total revenue was up 36.1% and the gross margin rose 130 basis points. The invoice amount per shipment climbed 23% from last year. 

More articles by John Kingston

Echo going to debt market; highly speculative ratings issued

Marten brokerage units’ strong performance contrasts with sluggish truckload results

Big report on Robinson, Landsstar sees strong performance but lurking problems