Top Moving Companies in Amherst, NY (May 2026)
The best mover in Amherst is Wayfinder Moving Services , earning 227 total reviews and a 91.6% positive score. We reviewed 146 moving companies serving Amherst to determine which providers deliver the strongest value and reliability.
For long-distance relocations from Amherst, our recommendation is Colonial Van Lines. With a strong national presence, they deliver transparent pricing, top-quality service, and consistently high customer satisfaction.
Colonial Van Lines
|
Safeway Moving
|
American Van Lines
|
Hi, I'm Michael Marshall from FreightWaves
I've helped thousands of people move over the last decade. Build your move plan in minutes.
-
Pryority Movers | 4.02
-
Colonial Van Lines | 5.0
-
PODS | 4.5
-
Budget Truck Rental | 4.3
Why Trust FreightWaves Checkpoint?
At FreightWaves Checkpoint, we routinely evaluate more than 4,000 moving companies across the country using a data-driven scoring system built around performance, accountability, and overall customer experience. Our editorial team assigns weighted scores to the factors that matter most to consumers planning a move.
Here’s how we rank movers:
Customer feedback (40%): Verified consumer reviews carry the most weight in our methodology. We evaluate overall ratings, review volume, consistency across platforms, and patterns in customer experiences to measure satisfaction and service reliability.
Complaint track record (20%): While issues can arise in any move, resolution matters. We review complaint history through public consumer databases, focusing on frequency, severity, and how proactively a company works to address and resolve disputes.
Pricing transparency (15%): Clear estimates, well-defined deposits, and straightforward contracts score higher in our system. We prioritize movers that make it easy to understand what you’ll pay — without hidden fees or vague pricing language.
Service offerings (12%): Companies that provide a wide range of services — including full packing, specialty item handling, storage solutions, and interstate moving — earn stronger marks for flexibility and convenience.
Online experience (8%): We look at how easy a company makes it to get information, request a quote, and understand its services online. Up-to-date websites, clear contact details, and responsive review engagement all factor into the score.
Company track record (5%): Longevity, proper licensing, and overall business stability also play a role. Movers with a consistent operating history and verified credentials receive higher marks.
Our rankings are updated regularly to reflect new data, evolving consumer feedback, and shifts in company performance — helping you compare movers with confidence.
Top-Rated Local Movers in Amherst, NY
A fresh start in Amherst doesn’t need to come with headaches. With trusted local movers, even quick moves across town are handled with ease.
Here are our picks for the best local movers to handle your relocation:
Top-rated movers in Amherst:
- Wayfinder Moving Services : 227 reviews (91.6% positive)
- TWO MEN AND A TRUCK: 246 reviews (78.9% positive)
- Corrigan Moving Systems: 224 reviews (95.5% positive)
- Best Buffalo Movers : 71 reviews (91.5% positive)
- Pryority Movers : 5 reviews (40.0% positive)
Wayfinder Moving Services
75 Comet Avenue, Buffalo, NY, 14216
Wayfinder Moving Services (DOT: 3104397) offers a range of services including full-service moving, interstate moves, packing, unpacking, and crating, making them a versatile choice for a variety of moving needs. They also provide services for small moves and have expertise in handling pianos. A notable downside is that Wayfinder Moving Services does not offer international moving services, which might be a limitation for customers looking to relocate overseas.
Additionally, while they offer a senior moving service, they do not provide a senior discount, which could be a consideration for budget-conscious seniors. Customers can conveniently request an instant email quote, and payment can be made via credit card. With their active status and commitment to addressing diverse moving requirements, Wayfinder Moving Services stands as a solid option for those planning a move.
"Movers were friendly, knowledgeable & fast working. Moved nearly 50 years of household goods in just over 2 hours."
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Professional and polite staff
- Efficient service
- Careful handling
- Quick moving process
- Good communication
Cons
- Damage to items
- Inaccurate estimates
- Delayed arrival or delivery
Services
- Full-service
- Out-of-state
- Senior moving
- Full unpacking
- Labor-only
- Piano
- Offsite storage
- In-state
- Accepts credit cards
- Full packing
TWO MEN AND A TRUCK
3860 Broadway, a1 , Cheektowaga, NY, 14227
TWO MEN AND A TRUCK (DOT: 2527384) offers a wide range of moving services, including full-service moving, interstate and intrastate moves, unpacking, and labor-only options. Customers can benefit from additional services such as junk and debris removal, as well as safe and piano moving, and they offer a 5% discount on local moving services. However, potential clients looking for climate-controlled storage or international moving services might be disappointed as these options are not available. Despite not providing senior or other specific discounts, the comprehensive services and storage solutions make it a versatile choice for many customers.
"Juan, Justin, and Jeffrey were thorough and efficient while also handling our items with care. Mitch from the office was accommodating. Couldn’t be happier—highly recommend the company!"
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Efficient service
- Professional and polite staff
- Careful handling
- Quick moving process
- Good communication
Cons
- Damage to items
- Unexpected charges
- Lack of communication
Services
- Full-service
- Out-of-state
- Junk hauling
- Senior moving
- Full unpacking
- Debris clean-up
- Labor-only
- Piano
- Offsite storage
- Heavy safes
- In-state
- Accepts credit cards
- Full packing
Corrigan Moving Systems
1845 Dale Rd, Buffalo, NY, 14225
Corrigan Moving Systems (DOT: 77949) stands out as a comprehensive moving company offering full-service moves and interstate, intrastate, and international capabilities. The company caters to a variety of client needs with climate-controlled storage, professional crating, and unpacking services, making them a versatile choice for most moving needs. A potential drawback for some customers might be the company's lack of fragile-only packing and acceptance of cryptocurrency payments. Although Corrigan Moving Systems provides senior moving services, they do not offer a senior discount, which could be a consideration for cost-conscious retirees.
"Ray, Spencer, Lucas, and Brian did an amazing job packing and loading our stuff for us. Very professional and nice people."
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Professional and polite staff
- Efficient service
- Careful handling
- Quick moving process
- Helpful movers
Cons
- Unexpected charges
- Misplaced or lost items
- Damage to items
Services
- Full-service
- Out-of-state
- Senior moving
- Full unpacking
- Offsite storage
- In-state
- Full packing
Best Buffalo Movers
392 Genesee Street, Buffalo, NY, 14204
Best Buffalo Movers offers comprehensive moving services, including full-service moves and unpacking options, making them a versatile choice for various needs. They cater to both small local moves and larger interstate relocations, providing convenience and flexibility. However, potential customers should note that they do not offer international moving services, which might limit options for those planning overseas relocations. Despite the absence of climate-controlled storage, their services include piano and pool table moving, ensuring the safe transport of specialized items.
"Would highly recommend! ... Rich was extremely accommodating with my last minute needs. The day after I called... moved things quickly- yet with care! All three of them were very helpful and sweet men. Will absolutely use them again!"
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Efficient service
- Professional and polite staff
- Careful handling
- Affordable rates
- Good communication
Cons
- Unprofessional behavior
- Delayed arrival or delivery
- Misplaced or lost items
Services
- Full-service
- Out-of-state
- Senior moving
- Full unpacking
- Labor-only
- Piano
- Offsite storage
- Heavy safes
- In-state
- Full packing
Pryority Movers
1616 Main Street, Niagara Falls, NY, 14305
Pryority Movers offers a comprehensive range of services, including full-service packing, international, and interstate moves. They also provide specialized services such as junk removal and unpacking, but they do not offer climate-controlled storage, which might be a downside for those needing temperature-sensitive storage solutions. While they cater to seniors, it's notable that they do not offer senior discounts, which could be an area of improvement for potential cost savings for older customers. For your convenience, Pryority Movers accepts multiple payment methods, including credit cards, and provides instant email quotes to streamline the moving process.
Great service. Arrived 2 hours earlier than expected today. These guys are very friendly and moved item with care. Was made aware they move everything from piano's to pool tables. Thanks again
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Careful handling
- Professional and polite staff
- Efficient service
- Quick moving process
- Helpful movers
Cons
- Unexpected charges
- Delayed arrival or delivery
- Unprofessional behavior
Services
- Full-service
- Out-of-state
- Junk hauling
- Senior moving
- Full unpacking
- Piano
- In-state
- Accepts credit cards
- Full packing
More New York Moving Options
Curious about all moving solutions near you? Check out this list of the best moving companies in New York.
The Best Long-Distance Movers in Amherst, NY
Leaving Amherst opens the door to countless new possibilities, whether your next stop is just beyond the border of New York or thousands of miles away. Partnering with a trusted interstate mover ensures your journey starts smoothly. Here are some of the best to guide the way:
|
Colonial Van Lines
|
Safeway Moving
|
American Van Lines
|
Colonial Van Lines
Colonial Van Lines (USDOT: 1434373) is a full-service moving company based in Pompano Beach, Florida, that handles long-distance moves across 48 states. With more than 50 years in the business and over 12,000 moves completed each year, they know their way around an interstate move. Colonial offers packing, storage, and long-distance transport throughout the continental US, all handled by highly trained crews. Their easy-to-use mobile app makes getting a quote quick, and customers often highlight the company’s friendly, professional, and reliable customer service.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Expert in-house crews
- Home electronics setup
- Trash & debris removal
Cons
- No local or international moves
- Not available in AK or HI
Services
- Long-distance moving (nationwide service across contiguous 48 states; excludes Alaska & Hawaii)
- Cross-country & interstate moving (full-service coordination from packing to delivery)
- Professional packing & unpacking (trained packers, specialty blankets, shrink-wrap, custom crating)
- Moving storage services (in-transit, short- & long-term climate-controlled storage options)
- Corporate & commercial relocation (efficient packing, storage, furniture assembly/disassembly)
- Full-service moving (end-to-end handling by CVLU-trained professionals)
- Customizable quotes via moving app or specialist (accurate, transparent estimates with virtual inventory)
- Colonial Moving App (virtual estimates, inventory updates, checklists, and box ordering)
- Colonial Van Lines University training (movers with 2–4 week curriculum and ~10-year average experience)
- Family-owned national service (50+ years, 250k+ moves, 4.6 Trustpilot rating)
Safeway Moving
Safeway Moving (USDOT: 3756000) is a veteran-owned moving company built around the idea of military-level precision. Thanks to its nationwide network of truck capacity, Safeway is able to offer very competitive pricing without cutting corners. The company also uses a multi-stage quality assurance process to keep moves on track from pickup through delivery. That combination of accurate pricing and consistent quality is a big reason Safeway earned a spot on our list.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- 30 days of free storage on all interstate moves
- Long distance and cross country moves only
- A portion of every move is donated to charity
- Verification process to guarantee pricing and quality of service
- High level of customer service and support
- Veteran owned company
Cons
- Require a deposit at booking
- No local moving services offered
Services
- Long-distance moving (all 50 states, GPS tracking, barcode-scanned inventory)
- Flat-rate pricing (virtual walk-throughs, no hidden fees)
- Price matching (meets or beats quotes from qualified competitors)
- Comprehensive insurance ($6/lb full-value protection option)
- Packing and unpacking services (includes last-minute packing for an extra charge)
- Custom crating (for fragile, heavy, or high-value items like art and electronics)
- Storage options (30 days free, climate-controlled, long-term available, prorated billing)
- International moving (limited info online, contact customer service)
- 24/7 customer service (available by phone at all times)
American Van Lines
American Van Lines (USDOT: 614506) is a long-distance moving company known for its hands-on approach and experienced crews. Based in Florida, the company handles interstate moves nationwide and stands out for using full-time, background-checked movers rather than temporary labor. American Van Lines offers packing, storage, and specialty services for items like antiques and pianos, with a strong focus on careful handling. Customers often point to the company’s professionalism and attention to detail as key reasons it earns high marks.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Excellent customer service
- Last-minute moves
- Private storage options
- Handles antiques, pianos & fine art
- Flat-rate pricing
Cons
- May require a deposit at booking
- Automated calls may be overwhelming
Services
- Local moving (affordable hourly rates, packing, custom crating)
- Long-distance moving (nationwide service, excludes Alaska and Hawaii)
- Packing services (upgrade to include professional wrapping, packing, inventorying)
- Antique and piano moving (specialized handling of fragile/oversized items, custom crating available)
- Military moves (in-home estimates, discounts, packing, storage, furniture assembly/disassembly)
- Corporate relocation (commercial moving, furniture disassembly/reassembly, storage)
- Storage options (secure, private units with surveillance, climate control, fire/storm protection)
- Moving boxes and supplies (available for purchase from AVL)
Allied Van Lines
Allied Van Lines (USDOT: 076235) is one of the most recognizable names in the moving industry, with a nationwide and global network backed by more than 80 years of experience. Alongside full-service local, long-distance, and international moves, Allied offers Allied Express, a portable container option that includes professional loading and unloading. With packing, storage, and specialty services also available, Allied provides flexible solutions for a wide range of moving needs.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Specialty packing services
- Short- and long-term storage
- Appliance disconnection & reconnection
- International shipping
Cons
- Pricing is generally higher than other van lines
- Pricing estimates can take 3-5 days
Services
- Household moving (local, long-distance, cross-country — packing, loading, transport, unloading, unpacking)
- Long-distance & interstate moving (contiguous U.S.; full-service options)
- International moving (130+ countries; online tracking, customs clearance, destination services)
- Military moves (PCS, deployment; temporary/in-transit storage; compliance with DoD regulations)
- Corporate & office relocation (employee moves, office packing, furniture disassembly/reassembly)
- Packing & unpacking services (professional crews, specialty materials, custom crating for fragile/odd items)
- Moving supplies & kits (boxes, shrink-wrap, moving kits available)
- Storage solutions (in-transit, short- & long-term climate-controlled units with security)
- Portable storage containers (rentable containers for packing/storing during move)
- Full-service moving coordinators & 24/7 support (dedicated move coordinator, transparent pricing, no hidden fees)
BLVD Moving
BLVD Moving (USDOT: 3342827) is a long-distance moving company that puts a strong emphasis on clear pricing and customer communication. The company coordinates interstate moves nationwide and is known for assigning a dedicated move coordinator to guide customers through each step of the process. With professional packing, storage options, and a focus on consistency from pickup to delivery, BLVD Moving is a solid choice for customers who want a more organized, transparent moving experience.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Full-time professional crews
- Flexible rescheduling
- Last-minute services
Cons
- Limited insurance options
- Limited pricing on website
Services
- Long-distance moving (nationwide interstate relocations coordinated across the contiguous US), Cross-country & interstate moving (full-service coordination from packing through delivery), Professional packing & unpacking (trained crews, high-quality materials, specialty packing for fragile items), Moving storage services (short- and long-term storage options through partner facilities), Dedicated move coordinator (single point of contact from quote to delivery), Transparent pricing model (detailed estimates based on virtual or phone inventory reviews), Carrier-vetted moving network (licensed and insured interstate carriers meeting BLVD’s service standards), Specialty item moving (oversized furniture, antiques, and delicate household goods), Customer support throughout the move (proactive communication and scheduling updates from pickup to drop-off)
Moving Services Offered in Amherst
Moving companies differ significantly in the services they provide, and what is available often depends on the specific location. Some movers boast expertise in handling delicate items, pianos, or even offer comprehensive storage options, whereas others might not have these services available in Amherst.
The table below breaks down how many movers in Amherst offer each service, alongside totals for New York and the U.S. as a whole. It’s a quick way to spot which options are widely available nearby and which could be harder to find.
| Service | Amherst | NY | U.S. Average |
|---|---|---|---|
| Packing | 5 | 142 | 3,055 |
| Unpacking | 5 | 137 | 2,954 |
| Packing materials | 3 | 51 | 1,816 |
| Piano | 4 | 114 | 2,283 |
| Antiques | 0 | 82 | 1,455 |
| Art | 0 | 91 | 1,439 |
| Standard storage | 4 | 130 | 2,664 |
| Climate-controlled storage | 1 | 64 | 1,045 |
| Fragile-only packing | 0 | 27 | 746 |
| Custom crating | 3 | 102 | 1,912 |
Full-Service Moving Alternatives
With full-service movers, every detail is covered — packing, transport, and unloading. Still, you have other choices if you want more control or lower costs, including container rentals, do-it-yourself truck rentals, and help from hourly moving crews.
PODS |
Budget Truck Rental |
Wayfinder Moving Services |
Did you know? DIY movers in Amherst can still get extra muscle on moving day. With 3 labor-only options, you can book help by the hour for loading and unloading.
FAQs
Do all Amherst movers handle out-of-state relocations?
Is it cheaper to move during certain times of the year?
Are Amherst movers insured and licensed?
Do Amherst movers offer discounts?
No, Amherst movers do not currently offer advertised discounts. However, you should always double-check with a moving rep when you call for an estimate, since many companies provide various promotions and deals, either ongoing or during certain times of the year.
Can I pay movers in cash in Amherst?
How many Amherst movers provide packing services?
Do any Amherst movers specialize in fragile or high-value items?
How many movers in Amherst provide storage options?
Amherst, New York Relocation Resources
