AI tech promises huge returns for logistics, but many companies are seeing disappointing results. Lean Solutions Group CEO Jack Freker reveals a critical flaw: 81% of firms neglect the organizational transformation needed for AI to truly deliver. Learn which processes need human intelligence, which can be automated, and how a balanced “expert in the loop” approach can drive real efficiency and prevent wasted tech investments.
Most logistics companies are investing in artificial intelligence without doing the organizational groundwork required to make it work, according to new research from Lean Solutions Group and Everest Group. The study, based on interviews with roughly 200 industry leaders, found that while 69% of companies have moved past isolated AI use, only 19% have redesigned their workflows — a gap that is driving widespread underperformance.
The findings matter to carriers, brokers, and third-party logistics providers because the costs of a failed AI implementation are not abstract. Freight brokerage is a 5% margin business, and 30% of respondents in the study reported below-expectation returns on their AI investments, according to Jack Freker, CEO of Lean Solutions Group. Many of those firms lack the internal consulting bench to manage a full transformation, leaving them cycling through three or four technology vendors with little to show for it.
“They’ve applied technology, but they haven’t gone deep into the fit and readiness of the organization — in terms of which are the appropriate functions for AI transformation, which are the tasks that need experts in the loop and humans in the loop to complete the task to gain real benefits here,” said Freker.
“They’ve got to take the step first to redesign, create new processes, and then determine which are the processes that still need humans, still need judgment, still need relationships — which are the processes that are maybe lower value, that are more repeatable, that can be automated in a fairly easy and low-risk manner.” — Jack Freker, CEO, Lean Solutions Group
The study also found that 72% of logistics decisions remain human-led. Freker pointed to accounts payable invoice processing and track-and-trace as areas where automation is already delivering measurable results. In one client example, 71% of invoices are now completed entirely by AI, saving 640 hours that staff have been redeployed to higher-value tasks. In another, a 130-person team is tracking 54,000 loads, while a separate client reduced route-deviation response times by 77% after layering AI onto a team of roughly 50 people monitoring high-value loads — allowing the company to remove 15 to 20 headcount from that function.
Freker drew a clear line around carrier sales and customer sales, calling them areas where AI should augment rather than replace human workers. Because of the relationships and judgment involved, he said, those functions need to be treated more carefully. By contrast, he said emails are now 90% AI-handled for some clients, and functions such as invoice matching, proof-of-delivery, payment collections, appointment scheduling, and quote responses are well-suited to full automation.
Lean Solutions Group, which Freker said has been operating for 14 years and now works across six countries following recent acquisitions, has developed a product called Decision Intelligence — a one-click connection to client systems designed to give individual agents what Freker described as an “Iron Man suit” that handles rote tasks and allows staff to increase the number of customer and carrier contacts made per day. The company positions itself as an expert-in-the-loop alternative for brokers and logistics firms that have tried pure technology plays without success.
- Only 19% of logistics companies have redesigned workflows for AI, even as 69% have moved past isolated use, per a Lean Solutions Group and Everest Group study of ~200 industry leaders.
- 30% of AI adopters in the study reported below-expectation returns; one client example showed AI handling 71% of invoices and saving 640 hours of manual labor.
- Carrier sales and customer sales are flagged as high-risk areas for AI replacement due to the judgment and relationships involved, while track-and-trace and back-office tasks show strong automation results.
This Summary is generated thanks to a transcription of the interview, for the full interview please enjoy the video above.