Spot rates are climbing, defying falling fuel prices. Dive deep into the National Truckload Index (NTI) data with FreightWaves to understand this unusual market divergence. We’ll explore the real drivers behind rising spot rates and what it means for holiday shipping and your supply chain strategy.
Dry van spot rates jumped to their highest level since July in early November, even as diesel prices declined — a divergence that points to capacity constraints and a late-season inventory surge rather than fuel cost pass-throughs. The National Truckload Index, which measures all-in dry van spot rate movement across the United States, rose more than 4% since late October while diesel truck stop prices fell roughly 3.5% over the same period.
The timing is notable. Julie Van de Kamp, reporting on the data as of Tuesday, November 17th, said the early-November move is unusual. “It’s rare that the NTI starts jumping this early in November ahead of the holidays,” she said, underscoring that the market is behaving differently than seasonal norms would suggest.
The disconnect between fuel and spot rates is a key theme. Diesel has not seen a sharp increase since early September, yet spot rates have continued to climb throughout that stretch. Van de Kamp was direct about the relationship: spot rates are primarily a function of available capacity and supply and demand, not a straight pass-through of fuel costs — and the current data reinforces that view.
“Carriers can’t always pass those fuel costs along unless the market bears it. And so we’ve also seen in prior cycles when fuel rates or costs have risen and spot rates have fallen, and we’re seeing the opposite right here.”— Julie Van de Kamp
A last-minute inventory push by retailers appears to be a significant driver. Van de Kamp pointed to the October Logistics Manager Index reading of 66.9 for inventory level growth — the highest reading since 2022 — discussed by Zach Strickland and Dr. Zach Rogers on Freightonomics. Many retailers delayed bringing holiday inventory into the country, a byproduct of demand uncertainty, rising inventory holding costs, and more streamlined supply chains. That compressed ordering window is now pushing freight outside of contracted agreements and into the spot market, adding upward pressure on rates.
The spot market itself represents only a fraction of overall truckload volume — roughly 10% to 25% of truckload freight depending on market conditions — with the remainder moving under contract. That means even a modest surge of freight spilling out of contracted agreements can move spot rates meaningfully.
National dry van tender rejection rates have been trending lower since July but remain between 10% and 15%, a range Van de Kamp describes as still capacity-constrained. Rejection rates above 10% are considered a sign of a tight market, and the current level gives carriers some ability to select freight that fits their networks without the extreme readings seen over the summer. The truckload market, she said, is “still really not fully recovered” and remains in what she characterized as an unhealthy state — but one where carriers retain meaningful optionality heading into the holiday stretch.
- The NTI rose more than 4% since late October while diesel prices fell 3.5% over the same period, decoupling spot rates from fuel costs.
- A record-high October Logistics Manager Index inventory reading of 66.9 — the highest since 2022 — points to a last-minute retailer inventory surge driving freight onto the spot market.
- Dry van tender rejection rates remain between 10% and 15%, signaling a capacity-constrained market that still gives carriers some freight selectivity.
This Summary is generated thanks to a transcription of the interview, for the full interview please enjoy the video above.