As Congress begins work on a new long-term transportation bill, Dems propose a full-scale study on the safety of new HOS rules
The newly minted hours-of-service (HOS) final rule will require an extensive safety review that would delay the effective date of the rules by up to 18 months or even longer if Democrats on Capitol Hill have their way.
A “comprehensive review” of the final rule, which became official on Monday and is currently scheduled to go into effect on Sept. 29, was included in the Investing in a New Vision for the Environment and Surface Transportation in America (INVEST in America) Act, a five-year, $494 billion surface transportation reauthorization bill unveiled Wednesday by the U.S. House Transportation & Infrastructure Committee.
“I am proud to bring together the ideas and the needs into one transformational bill that will catapult our country into a new era of how we plan, build and improve U.S. infrastructure,” commented Committee Chairman Peter DeFazio, D-Oregon, in rolling out the 864-page bill.
Language within the legislation, which authorizes over $3 billion for motor carrier safety assistance and operations programs for fiscal years 2022 to 2025, states that the secretary of transportation “shall delay the effective date of the final rule published on June 1, 2020 … until 60 days after the date” on which the secretary submits the review to Congress. The review itself is to start no later than 60 days after the reauthorization goes into effect.
In carrying out the review, “the Secretary, in consultation with State motor carrier enforcement entities, shall undertake a statistically valid analysis to determine the safety impact, including on enforcement, of the exemptions, waivers, or other allowances” that limit the applicability of the final rule, according to language in the bill.
The study would be conducted by using either available data or data collected from motor carriers and drivers on fatigue-related incidents “and other relevant safety information related to hours of service” among carriers and drivers allowed to operate under each exemption or waiver.
The bill’s language requires the Secretary of Transportation to publish the findings of the review in the Federal Register, and to include a public comment period, no later than 18 months after the start of the review.
A potential challenge to the rule by safety advocates questioning its effectiveness could also cause a lengthy delay or possible changes to the final rule.
The total legislation package, which has yet to be vetted by Republicans on the committee, is a streamlined version of a $760 billion infrastructure “strategy” announced by House Democrats in January. It would be used for negotiating with the Senate over that body’s $287 billion proposal to replace the FAST Act, which is set to expire at the end of September.
Acknowledging that the bill is in its early stages, David Heller, vice president of government affairs for the Truckload Carriers Association, was wary about any delay in the HOS final rule.
“Allowing drivers to adjust their day, particularly the new flexibility provided in the sleeper berth provision, is a major benefit to truckload carriers as a whole,” Heller told FreightWaves. “Any delay in the final rule would mean waiting that much longer to gain that flexibility.”
Also included in the legislation is funding for truck parking grants, a requirement to establish limits on detention times by shippers if drivers are not compensated, and restoring public availability of driver safety scores compiled through the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s Compliance, Safety, Accountability (CSA) program.
Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association (OOIDA) President and CEO Todd Spencer commented that “there’s a lot to like about this bill if you’re an OOIDA member, but some aspects will need to be improved,” noting specifically the HOS and CSA score proposals.
