Shipbuilder sued by owner, operator of ship in deadly Baltimore bridge collapse 

Lawsuit alleges defective design led to power loss

(Photo: Key Bridge Response 2024 Unified Command/U.S. Coast Guard Petty Officer 3rd Class Carmen Caver)
Gemini Sparkle

Key Takeaways:

  • The owners and operators of the container ship Dali are suing its builder, Hyundai Heavy Industries (HHI), for negligence resulting in a deadly bridge collapse.
  • The lawsuit alleges a defective control panel design caused a power outage, leading to the ship losing control and colliding with the Francis Scott Key Bridge.
  • The National Transportation Safety Board's report supports the claim of a loose wire causing the power outage and subsequent disaster.
  • Despite previously denying wrongdoing and paying $102 million in settlements, the plaintiffs are now seeking further damages for repairs and third-party claims.
See a mistake? Contact us.

The owner and operator of the container ship involved in a deadly Baltimore bridge collapse in March 2024 are suing the ship’s builder, alleging a defective control panel design caused a power outage that led to the disaster.

The Dali twice lost power as it was departing Baltimore harbor and drifted out of control into a support of the Francis Scott Key Bridge, collapsing the span and killing six highway workers.

The collapse also caused an extended supply chain snarl at the Port of Baltimore, which hosts a major coal terminal and had been the leading U.S. hub for vehicle imports.    

In a lawsuit filed July 31 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, owner Grace Ocean Private Limited and operator Synergy Marine Private Limited accused Hyundai Heavy Industries (HHI), the ship’s builder, of negligence that caused the fatal incident.

The plaintiffs charged that a defective design, specifically a loose wire in an electrical switchboard, caused a power outage at 1:25 a.m. the night of the collapse, cutting power to the engine and steering systems.

The National Transportation Safety Board in a 2024 report found that a cable that should have connected to a control for blackout protection was loose. That could have caused the switchboard to lose power without being detected.

Grace Ocean and Synergy Marine have denied wrongdoing since April 2024 but late that same year agreed to pay $102 million for civil claims brought by the federal government and other incident-related costs.

The plaintiffs are seeking damages for vessel repairs and coverage for any third party claims.

Find more articles by Stuart Chirls here.

Related coverage:

China trade fight weakens Matson earnings

Panama ports sales challenge could turn into Trump win

Why a French shipping magnate with US ties is interested in China-owned port terminals 

Rail deal will open new markets for top US container port 

Stuart Chirls

Stuart Chirls is a journalist who has covered the full breadth of railroads, intermodal, container shipping, ports, supply chain and logistics for Railway Age, the Journal of Commerce and IANA. He has also staffed at S&P, McGraw-Hill, United Business Media, Advance Media, Tribune Co., The New York Times Co., and worked in supply chain with BASF, the world's largest chemical producer. Reach him at stuartchirls@firecrown.com.